Table of contents
Even an impeccable reputation and integrity may not be enough when there is a fraudster on the other side of the transaction. Our client experienced this when he received a letter demanding payment of EUR 200,000 for an alleged breach of a non-compete clause. Why? Because he had performed a transport acquired legally on a freight exchange, and the load turned out to have been posted by a client of his principal.
- Allegation of breaching the non-compete clause
- A misunderstanding or a lack of diligence?
- Course of the proceedings
- The penalty claim was dismissed
Allegation of breaching the non-compete clause
A Polish carrier performed regular international transport. He accepted one of the orders from a freight exchange, and the transaction did not arouse his suspicion. Only later did it turn out that the principal was accusing him of breaching the non-compete clause and demanding EUR 200,000 as a contractual penalty.
– When I saw the amount, I genuinely felt faint. Nobody pays 200 thousand euros for an ordinary transport! – the carrier did not hide his irritation.
A misunderstanding or a lack of diligence?
In the principal’s view, accepting the order meant that the carrier had provided a service directly to its client and thus breached the non-compete clause set out in the contract.
Our client took a different view – he had obtained the transport from a publicly available freight exchange, so it was hard to speak of underhandedly acquiring a client or acting to the detriment of a business partner. An amicable settlement was out of the question, so the dispute ended up in court.
Course of the proceedings
The first step was to analyse the documents and the clauses in the contract. We checked whether the penalty could have been validly charged at all and whether the non-compete clause was lawful.
The contractual provision analysed, contained in the transport order, read as follows: “Within 3 years of the last transport order received from the Principal, the Contractor undertakes not to contact, directly or indirectly, Clients met through the Principal, and not to offer the Principal’s Clients the provision of such services, on pain of a contractual penalty of EUR 200,000.”
Such a clause will not be effective for four reasons:
1. No specific obligation defined – the above contractual provision does not indicate any specific obligation to be complied with, e.g. submitting offers. The carrier would therefore have to perform all the individual acts that make up the breach.
2. The order contains no list of business partners, so the carrier has no idea which business partners are meant. In theory, before concluding each contract of carriage, the carrier would have to ask its counterparty whether it cooperates with a particular entity, which would be an extraordinary burden.
This is confirmed by the prevailing view in case law, in particular that presented by the Court of Appeal in Warsaw in the statement of reasons for its judgment of 16 October 2013 (case ref. I ACa 682/13), that an overly general definition of such a scope does not deserve protection and is not effective.
3. Grossly excessive contractual penalty – the amount of a contractual penalty should correspond to the potential damage suffered by the freight forwarder as a result of the breach of the non-compete clause. Otherwise, the party breaching the non-compete clause will be entitled to have its amount “reduced”.
Alternatively
4. No monetary compensation specified for the carrier for the duration of the prohibition set out in Transport Order No. SO 531/12/2020 of 03.12.2020.
In view of the above, when drafting a non-compete clause, we should remember, among other things, to:
– specify the period for which the prohibition applies,
– specify the scope of entities covered, so that it is not too broad and is precisely defined,
– state precisely the amount payable for a breach of the prohibition,
– specify monetary compensation for complying with the non-compete clause.
– state clearly in the clause what is to be understood as competing activities – what specific activity will constitute competing activity.
In further steps:
- we prepared a defence to the statement of claim,
- we analysed the principal’s allegations and supported our conclusions with case law and legal literature,
- we represented the carrier in court,
- we demonstrated that the contractual penalty provisions were invalid and that there was therefore no basis for applying the penalty.
The penalty claim was dismissed
The court found in favour of our client, held the penalty to be ineffective and dismissed the claim in its entirety. In addition, reimbursement of the costs of the proceedings was awarded to the carrier.
– This situation shows that a clause in a contract is not everything – it must be drafted in accordance with the law, not just “look threatening” on paper – says Paweł Łazarewicz, who handled the case.
Thanks to precise analysis and solid arguments, our client avoided a high penalty, regained peace of mind and was able to continue his business without the risk of losing liquidity.
Situations like this occur in the sector more often than they should. That is why it is worth remembering: if something looks absurd, it very likely is, so it is worth asserting your rights with the support of experienced lawyers.
This article is for information only and reflects the law as of its publication or last update. It is not legal advice – for your own case, consult a lawyer.