Compensation for a leased truck – how not to lose out on the valuation of the wreck after an accident

Updated Maurycy Kieruj

Table of contents
  1. What was at the heart of the dispute?
  2. What did we do?
  3. The outcome
  4. What does this case show?

Accidents happen even to the best drivers. But in transport, the biggest problem is often not the collision itself – it is the subsequent settlement with the insurer. When a truck is leased, any error in the valuation of the damage can mean tens of thousands in real losses, even though the driver was not at fault in any way.

This is exactly the situation in which a transport company that came to our law firm found itself. The damage to the vehicle after a serious road incident was classified as a total loss. The insurer of the party at fault valued the salvage of the vehicle at PLN 75,000 and reduced the compensation paid by that amount.

The problem? No one on the market was willing to pay even a similar price for the wreck. Real, obtainable offers were in the region of PLN 30,000. The difference – PLN 45,000 – was to be borne by our client.

As the owner of the company told us:

“In transport, an accident is a risk that comes with the job. But I did not expect that the biggest problem would not be on the road, but on the loss adjuster’s desk.” Client, before action was taken

What was at the heart of the dispute?

The question was simple, though it had huge consequences:

Can an insurer reduce compensation by the value of a wreck that no one will actually pay?

Industry practice is clear – it cannot.

The value of the salvage must be based on real transactions, not on tables, algorithms or internal estimates. Meanwhile:

  • there was not a single purchase offer for PLN 75,000,
  • the insurer did not present a new, binding offer,
  • the real market price was approx. PLN 30,000.

This meant one thing: the compensation had been understated at the expense of the injured party.

What did we do?

After taking over the case:

First, we analysed all the claim documentation – the insurer’s decision, the expert assessor’s report, the correspondence with the leasing company and the offers to buy the salvage. We then prepared a legal position in which we clearly showed that the valuation of the wreck must be based on the sale price that can actually be obtained, not on the loss adjuster’s expectations.

We relied on the legislation and case law, and also pointed out that the current valuation led to so-called secondary damage – that is, to unjustified impoverishment of the injured party.

We started negotiations. After several weeks of intensive exchange of letters, the insurer changed its position.

As one of our lawyers who handled the case said:

“The difference between theory and practice is simple: either someone really will pay 75 thousand for the wreck – or that amount has to be verified. There was no doubt about it here.” – Legal counsel handling the case, Maurycy Kieruj

The outcome

The insurer corrected the valuation and accepted the real value of the salvage of PLN 30,000. The client received an additional payment of PLN 45,000, so the damage could be settled without financial loss and the lease closed in the normal way.

“In the end, we came out of it without a loss. Honestly – on our own we would not have stood a chance.” – Client after the case was resolved

What does this case show?

This is one of the most common pitfalls in settling total losses – especially for transport companies operating on leases. A high, “theoretical” value of the wreck may look good as an entry in a table – but in practice it means a real loss.

That is why the most important thing is to:

  • not accept decisions “automatically”,
  • check the market and possible offers,
  • react quickly, before the decision becomes final.

Because in many cases – as here – the right action can change the outcome by tens of thousands of zlotys.

This article is for information only and reflects the law as of its publication or last update. It is not legal advice – for your own case, consult a lawyer.

Find the right service

What challenge is your company facing today?

Choose the topic you want to start with. You can select more than one answer.