Table of contents
In transport, there are situations in which we breach certain elements of them – even if they do not affect safety or punctuality. This is exactly what our Client, a Polish carrier performing international transport, had to face.
After completing the carriage, he was informed that the Principal… would not pay a single zloty. The reason was supposedly the transhipment of the goods during the performance of the order. The contract provided for a contractual penalty of 100% of the freight charge for this, so the Principal issued a debit note and set off the entire amount due.
For the carrier, this meant one thing – work done, but zero payment.
“I was convinced that since the transport had arrived, the documents were in order and the consignee had received the goods, there was no issue. Meanwhile, the Principal decided not to pay me anything. A total surprise.” – owner of a transport company
What did we do?
First, we carefully analysed the contract and the contractual penalty clause to check whether it was effective at all and whether it could be applied on such terms. The transhipment of the goods – although not in line with the order concluded – caused neither damage nor delay; the clause providing for such a penalty was permissible and valid, but a penalty of 100% of the freight charge was grossly excessive.
We agreed a litigation strategy with the Client and took action:
- we prepared a response to the debit note and to the set-off statement,
- we drafted a statement of claim for payment of the freight charge,
- we responded to the other party’s objection, presenting arguments and case law,
- we filed a motion for reduction of the contractual penalty, pointing out that a sanction of this amount was disproportionately high.
We represented the Client at the hearing, where our arguments made it possible to break down the narrative of the Principal, who treated the transhipment as a serious breach of contract.
“In cases of this kind, the question is not only whether the penalty was written into the contract, but whether applying it is proportionate and consistent with the principles of law. A contractual penalty of 100% of the freight charge is grossly excessive and should be reduced – and that was also the case here.” – legal counsel handling the case
Outcome of the case
The court accepted our arguments:
- the penalty was reduced by as much as 85%,
- the remainder of the claim was awarded to our Client,
- after the judgment, we carried out successful enforcement of the receivable.
The carrier received part of the freight charge for the service performed, and the case confirmed that even if a penalty is written into the contract, this does not mean it must be enforced in full.
In transport, professionalism counts, but so does defending yourself against unfair practices. Rather than accepting the problem, it is worth fighting for what you are owed.
This article is for information only and reflects the law as of its publication or last update. It is not legal advice – for your own case, consult a lawyer.