Table of contents
Every carrier knows the feeling: you drive according to plan, everything is delivered on time, and then unloading suddenly turns into several days of waiting at the ramp because the other side is not ready. Our client went through exactly this situation – except that the unloading also dragged on into the weekend, and the counterparty refused to pay for the downtime, relying on contract terms excluding any charges for downtime.
The client’s situation
A Polish carrier performing an international transport arrived for unloading on time. Unfortunately, the goods were not accepted – and this went on for several days. The truck stood in the yard, the driver waited, and every hour meant a real loss:
- no possibility of performing further orders,
- additional costs.
When the carrier issued a debit note, the counterparty replied that – under the contract – it does not pay for downtime.
“What hurt most was that it was not our fault – and yet we received no additional payment for the downtime at unloading, which was caused by the consignee of the goods.” – Client, carrier
What we did
We started by analysing the documents and checking whether the contract terms really deprived the carrier of the right to compensation.
We quickly established that we could proceed on two tracks:
- claim the contractual penalty agreed earlier between the parties,
- or calculate the actual damage.
We chose the option that was more favourable financially and operationally. We then:
- helped the client issue a debit note for the downtime in a specified amount based on the contractual penalty,
- prepared a demand for payment describing the legal consequences,
- started talks with the principal.
The solution
The negotiations were matter-of-fact and firmly based on the terms of the contract of carriage – we showed that it is the principal who is liable for the delay in unloading the goods , and that the attempt to shift liability onto the carrier for the delay in unloading the goods had no basis.
As a result, the debit note was paid and the matter was closed without having to take it to court.
“This is an example of a situation in which the contract terms, after careful analysis, entitle the carrier to compensation for delay in unloading and downtime . It is not only the carrier that is liable for delay in unloading the goods” – Lawyer handling the case
Summary
Thanks to a quick response and well-conducted argumentation:
- the carrier obtained compensation for the downtime,
- it did not have to enter into costly litigation.
Situations like this show one thing: even if the other side relies on “hard contract terms”, it is worth checking them – because the law is often on your side.
This article is for information only and reflects the law as of its publication or last update. It is not legal advice – for your own case, consult a lawyer.