Is a contractual penalty for subcontracting carriage equal to the freight charge justified?

Updated Paweł Łazarewicz

Table of contents
  1. The court’s decision versus litigation practice
  2. What grounds allow a penalty to be reduced?
  3. A successful outcome and a much lower penalty

Clauses imposing penalties for subcontracting carriage are appearing more and more often in transport contracts. Our client faced exactly this situation: they performed a transport through another carrier, for which the principal charged them a penalty of 100% of the freight charge. Representing them in court, we argued that the contractual penalty for subcontracting was disproportionate to the scale of the breach. 

Our client received a transport order from the principal containing a contractual clause reading:

 “The Contractor may not subcontract the performance of this order to third parties/subcontractors without the express consent of the Principal, given in documentary form (by e-mail or via the trans.eu messenger)(…) In the event of a breach of this obligation, the Contractor shall pay a contractual penalty of 100% of the freight.”

Despite this, the client decided to subcontract the carriage to another carrier, and the transport itself went smoothly. After the service was performed, our client received a debit note from the principal equal to the freight charge, and the principal then set off the mutual claims, depriving the carrier of payment for the service performed. 

The court’s decision versus litigation practice

In response to the debit note, our client brought a case in court for payment of the invoice for the carriage service performed. The court issued a payment order, against which the principal filed an objection, relying on the contractual penalty for subcontracting the carriage and the set-off of mutual claims.

In the reply to the objection, prepared with the support of our law firm, I applied for the penalty to be reduced to 20% on the grounds that it was grossly excessive and that the claimant had performed the contract of carriage. 

Importantly, no damage occurred and the obligation was largely performed (Article 484 § 2 of the Civil Code), which constitutes grounds for reducing the penalty. This line of argument is confirmed by the Supreme Court judgment of 12 May 2006, V CSK 55/06, Lex no. 200875, and the Supreme Court judgment of 11 December 2008, II CSK 364/08, Lex no. 584727.

What grounds allow a penalty to be reduced?

The grounds for reduction, i.e. lowering the penalty imposed, are substantial performance of the obligation by the debtor and the contractual penalty being grossly excessive; both are of equal standing and independent of each other

A penalty may be shown to be “grossly excessive” by various circumstances, including those indicated in the judgment of the Supreme Court of 18 September 2019, IV CSK 487/18, namely:

  • the amount of the damage suffered,
  •  the ratio of the contractual penalty to the remuneration or to potential compensation under general rules,
  • gross disproportion of the penalty to the value of the entire principal obligation and the damage,
  • the value of the performance rendered late by the debtor,
  • a low degree of fault on the part of the debtor

In turn, according to the judgment of the Court of Appeal in Gdańsk of 12 March 2020, V AGa 117/19, Lex no. 3029854, stipulating a contractual penalty should not lead to unjustified enrichment of the creditor, and its reduction is intended to counteract disproportions between the amount of the stipulated contractual penalty and the creditor’s interest worthy of protection.

Important! As rightly stated in the judgment of the Regional Court in Łódź, case reference XIII Ga 632/22, reducing a contractual penalty by as much as 80% is permissible where no damage has occurred because the claimant has performed its obligations, so potential compensation under general rules would be much lower than 100% of the freight value.

A successful outcome and a much lower penalty

The case ended in a win for our client at both first and second instance, resulting in the penalty being reduced from 100% to 20%, so the client received 80% of the freight charge. This shows that stipulating penalties for subcontracting of 100% is ineffective and, as such, is highly likely not to be upheld in court proceedings.

This article is for information only and reflects the law as of its publication or last update. It is not legal advice – for your own case, consult a lawyer.

Find the right service

What challenge is your company facing today?

Choose the topic you want to start with. You can select more than one answer.