Table of contents
Transport to the United Kingdom is today one of the riskiest branches of international carriage. Inspections are strict, procedures have multiple stages, and a mistake – even a minor one made under stress – can mean enormous costs. Many carriers know this fear: the driver performs his duties, the inspection proceeds normally… and a few hours later a decision arrives imposing a penalty amounting to tens of thousands of pounds.
- A transport company with a GBP 36,000 penalty
- Where did the problem lie?
- Our actions
- Outcome
- Conclusions
A transport company with a GBP 36,000 penalty
This is exactly how the story of our Client began – a Polish transport company regularly serving the Calais-Dover route. After routine checks by the French authorities, the driver moved on with his documentation stamped. In line with the procedure, he fitted a new seal on the trailer and proceeded to the British inspection lane.
There, migrants were found hidden between pallets. Border Force decided that the security procedures had not been followed and imposed a penalty of GBP 36,000: GBP 18,000 for the company and GBP 18,000 for the driver.
As the business owner later said:
“My first thought? That this was the end. It is the situation you have feared for years – you do everything right, and yet you get a penalty that is hard to bear.”
Owner of a transport companyWhere did the problem lie?
It was not a lack of procedures. The company had checklists in place, appropriate instructions and regular training.
The only mistake – the driver did not hand the checklist to the British authorities for inspection. Not because it did not exist. Simply, during the tense, multi-stage inspection, no one asked him for it, and the driver – focused on the course of the rest of the inspection – forgot to formally hand over the document.
For Border Force, this was sufficient grounds to impose the maximum penalty.
Our actions
As soon as the case was reported to us, we took action immediately.
First, we carefully analysed the course of the entire inspection in Calais – including the fact that the French customs officers themselves had ordered the seals to be removed and had confirmed the condition of the load in the documents. We then prepared an appeal to Border Force in which we demonstrated, step by step:
- that the company has full procedures in line with the Civil Penalty Accreditation Scheme guidelines,
- that the driver carried out genuine checks,
- that the failure to hand over the checklist was a formal error, not a security breach,
- that the carrier provides an actual system for securing transport, and that the entire incident stemmed from the context of a stressful multi-stage inspection.
The lawyer handling the case later said:
“Border Force does not have to accept every argument – but it must see that the carrier acts systematically and actually controls what happens to the load. Here, that was beyond dispute.”
Paulina Eliasz-Petrusiewicz
Outcome
A few weeks later, the decision arrived:
The penalty was cancelled in its entirety. The Client did not pay a single pound – and neither did the driver.
“If we had not gone back to this case with the help of lawyers, we would have faced a loss of PLN 180,000. As it was, we were able to close the matter without any consequences.”
Client after the case was concluded
Conclusions
This story proves three things:
- the detection of immigrants does not automatically mean defeat,
- even a minor procedural error can be defended if the company genuinely operates in line with Border Force requirements,
- the response must be quick – because time works against the carrier here.
In transport to the United Kingdom, the pressure is growing year by year. But a well-prepared line of defence makes it possible to avoid even such costly and – seemingly – excessive decisions.
If you want to protect your company against the risk of such a penalty, see how we can help you obtain Border Force accreditation
This article is for information only and reflects the law as of its publication or last update. It is not legal advice – for your own case, consult a lawyer.