Case study: recovering the costs of a substitute carrier after a vehicle was not provided

Updated Transcash Legal

Table of contents
  1. What did we do?
  2. The court sided with the freight forwarder

A Polish freight forwarding company came to our law firm. It had to organise transport “right away” – with a fixed deadline and no margin for delays. Everything had been agreed, but on the day of performance the original carrier, without warning or explanation, simply failed to provide the vehicle. Unable to afford losing the order, the freight forwarder had to hire a substitute carrier at the last minute, and entrusted us with analysing the case in terms of the original counterparty’s liability.

– It was stressful. The client was waiting, the load was waiting, and we had hours to react. The cost of the substitute carrier was huge, but we had no choice – this is how a representative of the freight forwarding company described the situation to us.

What did we do?

We analysed the contract and all the circumstances. It was clear that the original carrier was liable for failing to provide the vehicle. The key was to demonstrate the damage – the difference between the original order and the substitute one – and to formally confirm that the freight forwarder had acted within the framework of substitute performance permitted by law.

In the course of the case, we handled:

  • the analysis of the contractual provisions and the carrier’s liability,
  • the assessment of whether it was justified to charge the carrier with the costs of substitute performance,
  • the calculation of the actual damage,
  • the conduct of the court proceedings,
  • and then successful enforcement by a bailiff.

The court sided with the freight forwarder

Ultimately, the court found in favour of the freight forwarder, thanks to which it recovered the entire difference in rates and suffered no loss on the order.

This case proves that failure to provide a vehicle for a fixed deadline is a classic example of carrier liability. If the freight forwarder acts quickly and documents the costs, recovering the difference is entirely realistic.

For companies operating under time pressure, such situations are particularly painful – fortunately, they can be resolved effectively, and the key is to document the circumstances and facts that will support our position in the dispute.

This article is for information only and reflects the law as of its publication or last update. It is not legal advice – for your own case, consult a lawyer.

Find the right service

What challenge is your company facing today?

Choose the topic you want to start with. You can select more than one answer.