Table of contents
Supply chains in transport can be complex. One weak link is enough, and the consequences fall not on the party at fault but on an honest carrier. That is what happened in this case – when a German subcontractor that had not been paid by a dishonest principal decided to hold our client’s goods and demanded a “ransom”. The case concerned the transport of approx. 30 pallets of beer – more than 19 tonnes in total – which overnight became stuck in the subcontractor’s private warehouse. How did we solve this problem?
How did it happen?
A Polish transport company commissioned a foreign freight forwarder to carry the goods. The problem was that the freight forwarder turned out to be a fraudster: it broke off contact and disappeared from the freight exchanges, and in addition unlawfully subcontracted the transport to another carrier, this time from Germany, giving it a fictitious route to Barcelona and then changing it to Belgium.
When the German carrier was not paid, it diverted with the load to its own warehouse and informed our client that it would release the goods only after more than EUR 8,000 in costs had been paid. The claims were supposedly based on a German statutory lien – even though the client was not a party to any contract with that company.
The goods were held, time was running out and the pressure was mounting. Every hour of delay increased the risk of losses, contractual penalties and loss of the consignee’s trust.
“I felt totally powerless. The goods had not been held through any fault of ours, yet someone was demanding thousands of euros that we should not have to pay.” – owner of the transport company
What did we do?
Our team had to act immediately. Within a few hours, we:
- carefully analysed the documents and correspondence,
- prepared a demand for release of the goods in German,
- started parallel business negotiations.
The key was to show that in international transport the applicable law is the CMR Convention, not local regulations. Under its provisions (Articles 13 and 12), the carrier may not hold goods because of the obligations of third parties – all the more so third parties with whom the client had no contractual relationship.
In the demand, we also pointed out that continuing to hold the load could be regarded as unlawful misappropriation under the German Criminal Code (§ 246 StGB).
At the same time, we challenged the amount charged – it included inflated costs for downtime, additional routes and items that had no basis in reality. In the interest of resolving the dispute quickly, we proposed a realistic, justified settlement amount that covered the carrier’s actual costs.
“In this case we had to be really firm and act on two fronts: legal and negotiating. The emotions were not only on one side – the German carrier also felt cheated. But the law here was unequivocal – our client could not bear the consequences of the freight forwarder’s unreliability.” – attorney handling the case
The outcome
A decisive, quick response produced a result that only a few hours earlier had seemed unrealistic:
- the German carrier released the load, so the goods reached the consignee,
- instead of more than EUR 8,000, the matter was closed for approx. 25% of that amount,
- the client avoided penalties and financial losses associated with having to pay compensation.
This case shows that even if a situation seems desperate, professional legal assistance can tip the balance in the client’s favour.
In transport, time matters – and a quick, well-handled intervention often makes all the difference.
This article is for information only and reflects the law as of its publication or last update. It is not legal advice – for your own case, consult a lawyer.