Successfully avoiding claims for damage to a BDF container on warehouse premises

Updated Maurycy Kieruj

Table of contents
  1. What was the situation?
  2. How did we help the client?
  3. The outcome
  4. What does this case show?

Accidents happen even to the best drivers. But in transport, the biggest problem is often not a collision – it is working with BDF containers in warehouses, which can be logistically demanding. New units arrive every day, dropped off by external drivers or shunters, and the warehouse has to operate quickly, smoothly and without downtime. At that pace, disputes arise easily – especially when the container owner reports damage and expects immediate payment for the repair.

This is exactly the situation in which a client came to us – the operator of a large cross-dock warehouse. The claim it received amounted to more than PLN 15,000. The container owner stated that the damage must have occurred on the warehouse premises and demanded compensation.

As is often the case, the problem arose suddenly:

“There was no warning beforehand. One day we simply received information that the container was damaged and that we had to pay for it.” – Client before action was taken

What was the situation?

The container was dropped off by an external shunter in the evening, in poor lighting. No formal acceptance report was drawn up – because in this sector such reports are very often simply not prepared. A few hours later, the container owner reported that the frame and side wall had been damaged, naming the warehouse as responsible.

The basic arguments behind the claim were simple:

  • the container had allegedly been “left in an intact condition”,
  • the damage was noticed after receipt by the warehouse,
  • so liability should fall on the operator.

The problem is that such reasoning is not automatic and raises several questions: Could the damage have occurred earlier? Is there evidence confirming the condition of the container before delivery? Should the warehouse operator actually be liable?

How did we help the client?

After receiving the report, we carried out a full analysis – both of the evidence and of the law.

First, we requested CCTV footage and data from the warehouse systems. We were able to establish that the container had been received after dark and that its technical condition had been confirmed neither by the shunter nor by the container owner. This was a key moment – the lack of evidence on the claimant’s side weakened its claim.

Together with an expert assessor, we also assessed the nature of the damage. The findings indicated that:

  • the deformation of the frame did not match the manoeuvres performed on the warehouse premises,
  • there were no fresh traces of contact with warehouse equipment,
  • the damage could have occurred much earlier.

On this basis, we prepared a legal position in which we demonstrated, among other things:

  • the lack of confirmation of the warehouse’s liability,
  • the lack of evidence of the continuity of events
  • the inconsistency of the claim with the principles of contractual liability.

We then began a formal exchange of letters with the container owner, showing that charging our client would be unjustified and risky – also for the claimant.

The outcome

After several days of negotiations, the container owner withdrew the claim in full. The client incurred no costs, and the whole process was closed at the pre-litigation stage.

“When we saw the official withdrawal of the claim, we felt enormous relief. For the first time, we felt that someone was really defending us and understood the specifics of our work.” – Client after the case was closed

What does this case show?

Not every claim concerning BDF containers has to end in an automatic payout. In many situations, a warehouse or carrier can successfully defend its interests – provided that it:

  • secures evidence quickly,
  • analyses the circumstances carefully,
  • uses legal support based on real knowledge of the sector.

This case shows that with the right approach high costs can be avoided – even when the other side makes tough demands.

If you want to prepare your business for similar situations, you can take the first step straight away. Log in to the Law Firm Panel and consult us about your case in a few minutes – quickly and without formalities.

This article is for information only and reflects the law as of its publication or last update. It is not legal advice – for your own case, consult a lawyer.

Find the right service

What challenge is your company facing today?

Choose the topic you want to start with. You can select more than one answer.